![]() Submission Link must lead to web-ace page of the chapter, and the scanlation link should be in the comments. There are a few ways to handle translated manga in general, moving forward: The gist of this section is, should User-Made Scanlations be allowed over Third-Party Scanlations? Or should there be no difference between the two? If we allow user translated comics, why not user translated manga? Or should it be on the same playing field as Third-Party Scanlations? We also have users and groups who are active on the subreddit that put in the effort to scanlate the manga themselves, one example being the Salem Manga translation. ![]() When a user on the sub links from them, what makes it different from what we discussed in the first section? Should it pass that logic because they are an English translation that people will look for through other means on the Internet anyway? These scanlations are done by independent groups that host their translations on illegal manga sharing websites, such as mangadex. To muddy things further, we have two types of manga translations on this subreddit: Unfortunately for a lot of these mangas, there is no official English translation provided for them, save for the Learning With Manga series from DW/Aniplex themselves. Ultimately we are an English-speaking community here and we largely consume English content. ![]() 2 - Discuss & Brainstorm: What should we do for translated manga? If the thread is largely filled with no, we will not implement this rule. Please give us a yes/no in the comments below in regards to this section. There's little sense in allowing posting of rehost illegal websites when you can just link the web-ace page, for instance. Most crucial is the viewership on the official website as it provides revenue to them directly. There are no paywalls to all this content and at best, illegal websites only get a week head-start. Here, a user has posted raws of a chapter from the Emiya Gohan manga that is rehosted on a third party platform, rather than the original web-ace pages. Moving forward, we wish to not allow submissions like this. We said back then that we may have a community discussion on this topic in the future, and after the user has promptly reminded us in Modmail recently, no time like the present to discuss this matter! 1 - Rule Proposal: Raw Manga MUST Be Properly Sourced - No Illegal Websites Allowed We rolled out the Rules Wiki 2 months ago, and within it, a user has asked us what we should do in regards to pirated manga. Lore Sunday for any and all lore discussions.Įrror message compilation with translation Who Would Win Wednesday for all power level discussion and what-if scenarios.įriend Request Hub for all friend requests.įree-Talk Friday for chatting about anything. ![]() >!Spoiler!< for spoiler tagging text: SpoilerĪchievement Monday for all achievements, including bond CE. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |